Movie Review: City of God (2002)
City of God (Cidade de Deus) is a highly acclaimed Brazilian movie directed by Fernando Meirelles which I had always wanted to see but never was able to until now. Based on a true story, the film takes place non-linearly and over the span of two decades in the City of God, a notorious slum west of Rio de Janeiro. The movie follows the path of two little boys: One of them, Rocket (Alexandre Rodrigues) has a passion for photography and is determined to rise above the poverty, destitution, and gang-related violence that is omnipresent around him. Too smart to be a fishmonger, too kind to be a gangster, Rocket is trying to escape from the destitute life he seems fated to live. The second boy is Li’l Ze (Leanadro Frimino da Hora) who rises on to become City of God’s most powerful and ruthless gang leader. Li’l Ze is wild and unpredictable and has no qualms taking lives for the slightest offense. The movie is mostly focused on the violent rise and fall of Li’l Ze as seen through the eyes (and camera) of Rocket.
Strikingly, City of God is very similar to 2008′s Slumdog Millionaire as Slumdog is almost an identical ripoff of this movie. It is quite similar in that it also depicts the harsh life in the slums of a major city, uses some of the same non-linear chronological tricks used in City of God, and has the same stereotypes of characters inhabiting its harsh world. On the other hand, City of God is in many ways much more grim, shocking, and brutal. Meirelles is not afraid to give some of his most shocking scenes time to sink in. One of the most memorable scene is the one where Li’l Ze asks little kids, barely 7 or 8, whether they want to get shot in the hand or in the foot. After shooting them, he then ask another little boy to execute one of the two. The volatile and ruthless behavior of not only Li’l Ze but also the “Runts”, packs of 7 or 8 yr-old kids with guns (!!!) keeps you on the edge of your seat as you wonder whether someone is going to die needlessly once more. Is reality too hard to take? The movie is not all bleak and the viewer can find a little comical relief with a small section of the movie dedicated to Rocket’s desire to find love or his few puny attempts at becoming a criminal. He never finds the strength to hold-up anyone because everyone he meets are so kind to him and he quickly gives up. Unlike your average Hollywood movie, those scenes are not contrived or used as time filler but fit in perfectly with the rest of the movie and give relevant background into one of the main character.
The performance in the movie are first-rate especially when you learn that only one of the character was played by a professional actor while everyone else was people hand-picked from the slums. The cinematography is superb with major part of the movie shot with hand-held cameras which gave the movie a gritty first-hand experience atmosphere. The musical score is also first rate to complement a well crafted movie.
A haunting, yet beautiful view into the harsh and desperate life inside a favela, City of God is one of the most memorable movie you will ever see.
A
Notes: Rated R for strong brutal violence, sexuality, drug content and language. 130 minutes.











5 Comments
Whenever anyone asks me to recommend a good foreign film, this always tops my list of suggestions. You are absolutely correct in calling out “Slumdog” as a ripoff, for although “Slumdog” fancied things up a bit with Rahman’s score and that dance number at the end, the coming-of-age-in-hard-times plot is the same. Only “City of God,” in my opinion, does a much more credible, less fanciful job.
Though Slumdog was a great film in its own right, there are plenty of elements taken from this one. The screenplay for this film is a lot better than Slumdog and is positioned a lot better, when it comes to the camera angles. This is better than Slumdog and I think with the disturbing scenes and violence will leave its mark on any critic when first watching.
I understand about comparing this movie to “Slumbog Shit-In-There”. They are somewhat similar, but I hate Slumbog. It was fairy tale that I wished didn’t have a happy ending. City of God was a real visceral take on the life in the slums.
This flick is so fantastic and twisted. My question is was City of Man supposed to be a sequel to this? I watched part of that and stopped… it just paled by comparison.
Leave it to the Academy to shun this for best picture, but give Slumdog the Oscar.
Trackbacks