Doubleheader Reviews: ‘The Adventures of Tintin’ is Breathlessly Entertaining

Sam Fragoso: What a delight The Adventures of Tintin is. Directed by master craftsman Steven Spielberg this exciting and jubilant roller-coaster ride of a film is a well-welcomed surprise, guaranteed to please audiences of all ages.

Based of the comic books series by Hergé the film follows adolescent journalist Tintin (voiced by Jamie Bell), his faithful dog Snowy, and Captain Haddock (Andy Serkis) as the they embark on a treasure hunt for a sunken ship that was initially commanded by an ancestor of Haddock’s 300 years ago.

However, where there’s a valuable treasure, there are others with the same objective. Ivanovich Sakharine (Daniel Craig) is their biggest threat – a tyrannical, wealthy, and vile individual looking for the third model ship called the Unicorn. Our plot eventually expands. Tintin, Haddock, and Sakharine are all puzzled, desperately looking for the third and final replicate ship. Within these beautifully crafted models is a small note. Once one collects all three scrolls, the lustrous treasure is revealed.

As the three major players (amongst other subplots) venture around the world, they ultimately end up in Morocco – where the court of Sheikh contains the prized third model. Plenty of brilliantly framed action sequences ensue revolving around their quest for the Unicorn.

My explanation of the story may seem rather pedestrian and straight forward – but The Adventures of Tintin is anything but. At last we have received a complex animation film that has an engrossing and dense mystery at its core. The animation incorporated is mesmerizing and downright stunning. Every shot, shadow, reaction, and scene is captured with exuberance and suspense.

Its faults run deep – but don’t diminish the experience to unwatchable. Made by Nickelodeon it certainly has the typical, manufactured traits that only satisfy children. Which would be fine if the picture was punctuated with such elevated language and serious social commentary.

For being a mere hour and 48 minutes, it feels far longer. The exposition isn’t the problem – it’s the misanthropic adventures that become tiresome. Again, though, these are minor quibbles that are ultimately overshadowed by the films plethora of positives: flawless editing, lucid voice work, and genuinely exhilarating action set pieces.

With The Adventures of Tintin I believe it’s time for the US to get behind the UK and the troves of love they have for this character and series. Who would’ve guessed an aesthetically gorgeous animation epic would ultimately mark Mr. Spielberg’s return to sincerity and most of all, quality?

The film was screened in 3D. Once again, the experience was underwhelming. Not worth the surplus.

B+

3 stars out of 4

You may follow me on twitter @DukeSensation

 

The Adventures of Tintin

Jordan Winter: Recently Steven Spielberg has been one busy man, not only has he been producing numerous television and film properties over the past year or so but he has also been juggling two directorial properties. While War Horse isn’t due to be released for another month, his latest offering, The Adventures of Tintin: The Secret of the Unicorn, is based on the classic, best-selling comic books created by the Belgian artist Georges Remi (also known under the pen name Herge).

The comics follow a young Belgian reporter named Tintin and his dog Snowy as they go about their days solving mysteries and getting into various misadventures along the way. Directed by Spielberg, produced by Peter Jackson and written by the British trio of Edgar Wright, Joe Cornish and Steven Moffat, the animation marks a new turn in Spielberg’s cinematic journey as he ditches live action for motion capture, and while the film takes full advantage of the technology at hand to create lavish environments, the story itself is too disorientating to hold an adult audience’s attention for its one hundred minutes run time.

As the film starts, Tintin (Jamie Bell) along with his faithful dog Snowy, is enjoying his day meandering around a local market when he finds an intricately designed model ship called the Unicorn available for sale by a somewhat anxious  merchant. As Tintin attempts to unravel the mystery behind the legend of the Unicorn and its secret cargo, he sets off a sequence of events which sees the young reporter come up against the mysterious Ivanovich Sakharine (Daniel Craig), befriend the alcohol-loving Captain Haddock (Andy Serkis), and help clueless Interpol agents Thomson and Thompson (Simon Pegg and Nick Frost) in their many endeavors. Action, adventure, explosions, and bumbling detectives follow as Tintin races throughout the world to solve the mystery of the Unicorn.

The Adventures of Tintin: The Secret of the Unicorn

It is a phrase which is thrown around a lot when evaluating films within the action-adventure genre, but The Adventures of Tintin is literally a non-stop thrill ride. But, while this phrase would usually contribute to the praise of a motion picture, in the context of this film, it becomes a part of the criticism. From the beautifully crafted opening titles to the closing scene, there isn’t a moment which goes by in which something isn’t being blown up, jumped on, ridden or used as a makeshift weapon. It is as if Spielberg doesn’t trust the primarily young audience members to actually engage with the film when a lavish action set-piece isn’t taking place, and because of this, the audience is presented with a film which becomes disorientating due to its constant fast and frenetic pace. Also, due to the narratives exhilarating pace, the film requires that many of its large set-pieces take place one after the over, thereby detracting heavily away from their overall impact on the viewer.

Aside from the fast-paced nature of the motion-picture however, the performance capture works well, as the computer generated backgrounds, locations and scenery are a startling indicator of how far technology regarding motion capture and three-dimensional imagery has come in the last decade. When it comes to the characters themselves however, while the motion capture allows for startling facial detail, it cannot replicate the emotional disparity of real human beings. The script written by three of the most promising British filmmakers at the moment contains a multitude of in-jokes, friendly humor and an attempt at characterization. But again due to the pace of the film, this aspect falls flat due to the central narrative stream taking precedence over everything else on-screen throughout its running time.

The Adventures of Tintin is a family-friendly, fast-paced, loose, action-adventure film that will no doubt be lauded by children across the land. It is essentially Spielberg doing what he does best: entertaining the public. But unlike the Indiana Jones series and E.T, among many of his other films, Tintin is unable to cross generational boundaries to become a film for audiences of all ages. While children will appreciate the non-stop, in-your-face action sequences which are constantly loud, bright and full of computer-generated destruction, older cinema-goers will no doubt become tired of the repetitive series of events.

With a Tintin sequel and even a trilogy potentially on the cards for the future, it would have been nice if Spielberg had attempted to scale back the action sequences for further plot and character development, rather than throwing every available device at the viewer hoping that something would eventually stick. While this approach may work with young children viewing the picture, it will almost certainly pass most adults by.

C+

(6/10)

Posted November 14, 2011.

TAGS: , , , , , , , , ,

18 Comments

  1. Ohhh wow. That’s disappointing.

  2. Interesting take on the film. When I saw the preview I said that it made me feel dizzy. I figured that was just the trailer doing what trailers do, but it sounds like the film as a whole actually follows the trailer in that regard.

  3. Castor says:

    I’m checking this out this weekend. Was a big fan of the comic strips as a kid and read all the books over and over again. Hopefully, this delivers.

  4. BrikHaus says:

    No surprises here. The typical Spielberg shit-express continues to roll on.

  5. Andrew says:

    Tintin is unable to cross generational boundaries to become a film for audiences of all ages.

    it would have been nice if Spielberg had attempted to scale back the action sequences for further plot and character development

    Disagree and disagree. I think the first point makes unfair assumptions about what adults look for in film entertainment, and Tintin is neither too dumbed-down for parents to enjoy nor too blown-up for kids to “get”. I mean, Spielberg’s not going Dreamworks on us; he’s telling a very precision-oriented adventure yarn.

    As for the second, the entire film hinges on the development of plot, so that really just leaves us with character development. Tintin himself doesn’t have much of an arc– he’s pretty much the same guy at the end as he is at the beginning– but he isn’t a cipher, either. He’s inquisitive human nature and curiosity personified. (In a way I think he’s our audience identification character, too.) Haddock has more of a personality and is much more of a rounded figure who undergoes something of an emotional journey. Given the parameters of the film I don’t think there’s much need for more than that.

    • Castor says:

      The thing is that Tintin actually has very little character development in the comic strips. There is very little known about the guy (no love interest, no real “personality” etc…) so it would be hard for this movie to stick to the character while making up things for his character arc.

      • Andrew says:

        I was actually wondering if Tintin really had all that much development in the books, so thanks for clearing that up.

        Interestingly enough it ties in well with a comment made in a Today show segment about The Adventures of Tintin in which someone remarked that “anyone could be Tintin” in regards to Herge’s dressed-down and minimalist style. I think that’s actually true of the animated character, too; he’s such a blank slate beyond his basic traits that any of us could be him.

        • Castor says:

          So you are saying he is the male version of Bella Swan? ;)

          • Andrew says:

            Bella’s actually more of a character than Tintin just by virtue of having a family and a history. She’s only firmly defined by her stalker obsession with Edward, but she’s also quirky (when necessary), smart (when necessary), sexy (when necessary), vulnerable (when necessary), and so on whereas Tintin never adds up to more than “boy reporter with a gun and a dog”.

            I think that works, though.

          • Castor says:

            Ah good point. I guess I was referring more to Kristen Stewart’s blank sheet performances.

          • Andrew says:

            Can’t reply to Cas’ nested comment directly, but yeah, you may be right about the preceived blankness being more due to Stewart than the character.

  6. ruth says:

    This is one of those critics-proof movies for me as I’ll see it for pure nostalgia factor. I mean, under PJ and Spielberg, it really can’t be that bad. I probably will end up loving the comics more but I’m still curious enough to check this out.

  7. Sam Fragoso says:

    I suppose my absence from commenting on here isn’t so much of a good thing.

    First off .. Jordan … interesting stance on the film and your points are taken – though I disagree, I respect your case.

    Through watching the brilliantly photographed action sequences I think you get a sense of what Tintin is like – through fear and danger, he is calm and reserved – alert and attentive – sincere and determined.

    I’m not quite sure how much character development you needed, but I felt that I had a rather affable grasp on our protagonist.

    As for … “Brikhaus” … I don’t even know where your remark came from. I thoroughly enjoyed the picture and Ms. Winter mildly had a good time. No shit nor disintegrating of “Tintin” came from here and or (going by RT and general consensus) any other site. You’re on your own.

    Andrew makes pragmatic points as usual.

    Ruth …. I still feel no film is critic proof. Sure, they’re films that writers can’t penetrate entirely – but it is what it is.

    And for the record … you all can call me Sam. I’m not like this Castor Troy guy who hides his name from everyone ;)

  8. Jaina says:

    I remember this film getting ripped to shreds by the critics over here on newsnight. They didn’t have a single good word to say about anything, from the motion capture to the characters to the plot. Oh wait, they loved Snowy.

    I for one enjoyed the film. 3D not withstanding, like Sam, I found the 3D completely underwhelming. It’s an entertaining film, fairly shallow and superficial.

    Am I right in remembering that Tintin didn’t actually really develop in the comics or subsequent cartoons either?

    • Momo says:

      Tintin (and every other character) was the same in every book. There was no development whatsoever, you could have read them from last volume to first without feeling like you missed anything. I mean, that is the case for pretty much every children comic books out there. I think people had too high expectations from this movie, which is really just an entertaining and action packed children comic and should be viewed as such.

      I’m looking forward to seeing it this weekend for entertainment value and nostalgia alone.

  9. Castor says:

    Just saw this on Monday morning (in IMAX 3D no less!) and I must say that although the movie can be ridiculously entertaining, I can’t quite grasp why I didn’t like it more than I did.

    As you say Sam, the movie feels longer than 108-minute runtime. I felt that it never truly got going until a good 40-minute into the story when Tintin and Haddock finally say aloud that they are going to look for Red Rackham’s treasure. Nonetheless, I enjoyed it. Spielberg did a really good job of staying true to the spirit of the comic strips.

Leave a Comment


Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Trackbacks

  1. New DVD Releases This Week – 3/13/12 — ANOMALOUS MATERIAL